Cold process soap vs commercial soap comparison infographic

Benefits of Cold Process Soap vs Commercial Soap

 

If you've ever wondered why handmade soap feels so different from the bars you buy at the grocery store, you're not alone. The truth is, most commercial "soap" isn't actually soap at all—it's detergent. And that difference matters more than you might think, especially if you struggle with dry, sensitive, or irritated skin.

In this guide, we'll break down exactly what makes cold process soap special, why it's gentler on your skin, and how to choose the right bar for your skin type. Whether you're dealing with eczema, acne, or just want healthier skin, understanding these differences can transform your daily routine.

What Is Cold Process Soap?

Cold process soap is made by combining oils (like olive, coconut, or shea butter) with lye in a chemical reaction called saponification. This process creates true soap while preserving the natural glycerin—a powerful humectant that draws moisture to your skin.

Unlike commercial soap, which is often made through hot process methods that strip away glycerin (to be sold separately for profit), cold process soap retains all of its skin-loving properties. The result? A bar that cleanses without stripping, nourishes without residue, and supports your skin's natural barrier.

Handmade cold process artisan soap bars with natural botanical ingredients arranged on marble surface

7 Key Benefits of Cold Process Soap

1. Natural Glycerin for Deep Hydration

Glycerin is a natural byproduct of the soap-making process, and it's one of the most effective moisturizers available. In cold process soap, glycerin stays in the bar, helping your skin retain moisture long after you've rinsed off.

Commercial soaps remove glycerin to sell it to the cosmetics industry, leaving you with a harsh detergent bar that dries out your skin. That tight, squeaky-clean feeling? That's your skin crying out for moisture.

2. Gentle, Skin-Safe Ingredients

Cold process soap is made with simple, recognizable ingredients: plant-based oils, lye (which is completely transformed during saponification), and optional natural additives like essential oils or clays.

Compare that to commercial soap, which often contains:

  • Synthetic detergents (SLS, SLES)
  • Artificial fragrances and dyes
  • Preservatives and hardeners
  • Petroleum-based ingredients

For sensitive skin, the difference is night and day.

3. pH-Balanced for Your Skin Barrier

Your skin's natural pH is slightly acidic (around 4.5-5.5), which helps protect against bacteria and irritation. True cold process soap has a pH of 9-10, which is higher but still gentle enough for most skin types when formulated correctly.

Commercial detergent bars, on the other hand, can have a pH as high as 11-12, which disrupts your skin's acid mantle and leads to dryness, irritation, and breakouts.

4. Customizable for Your Skin Type

One of the biggest advantages of artisan soap is that it can be tailored to your specific needs:

  • Dry skin: Soaps with shea butter, cocoa butter, or avocado oil
  • Oily/acne-prone skin: Soaps with activated charcoal, tea tree oil, or high-linoleic oils
  • Sensitive skin: Unscented soaps with oatmeal, calendula, or chamomile
  • Mature skin: Soaps with rosehip oil, sea buckthorn, or vitamin E

Commercial soap is one-size-fits-all, which means it's optimized for profit, not your skin.

Cold process soap creating rich moisturizing lather showing natural glycerin content

5. Eco-Friendly and Sustainable

Cold process soap is biodegradable, often packaged in minimal or recyclable materials, and made in small batches to reduce waste. Many artisan soap makers also source organic, fair-trade ingredients.

Commercial soap production, by contrast, relies on synthetic chemicals, plastic packaging, and mass manufacturing processes that contribute to pollution and environmental harm.

6. No Harsh Chemicals or Synthetic Additives

When you use cold process soap, you know exactly what's going on your skin. There are no hidden ingredients, no unpronounceable chemicals, and no synthetic fragrances that can trigger allergies or hormone disruption.

If you've ever experienced a rash, itching, or irritation from commercial soap, switching to cold process soap could be the solution.

7. Supports Small Businesses and Artisans

When you buy cold process soap, you're supporting small-batch makers who care about quality, sustainability, and customer satisfaction. You're not just buying soap—you're investing in craftsmanship and ethical business practices.

How to Choose the Right Cold Process Soap for Your Skin

Not all cold process soaps are created equal. Here's what to look for:

  • Check the ingredient list: Look for nourishing oils like olive, coconut, shea, or avocado. Avoid soaps with synthetic fragrances or dyes.
  • Consider your skin type: If you have dry skin, choose a soap with extra moisturizing oils. If you have oily skin, look for soaps with clay or activated charcoal.
  • Test for sensitivity: If you have sensitive skin, start with an unscented bar or one made with gentle ingredients like oatmeal or goat milk.
  • Support local artisans: Small-batch soap makers often use higher-quality ingredients and take more care in their formulations.

Experience the Difference with Our Artisan Soap Collection

Ready to upgrade your skincare routine? Our cold process soaps are handcrafted in small batches using premium botanical oils and natural ingredients. Each bar is designed to cleanse gently, nourish deeply, and support your skin's natural barrier.

Popular choices:

Shop our full collection and discover the difference that real soap can make.

Final Thoughts

Switching from commercial detergent bars to cold process soap isn't just a skincare upgrade—it's a commitment to healthier skin, cleaner ingredients, and a more sustainable lifestyle. Your skin deserves better than harsh chemicals and stripped-down formulas.

Try cold process soap for 30 days and see the difference for yourself. Your skin will thank you.

Back to blog